Defunding UNRWA will damage Palestinian-Israeli peace negotiations
LOS ANGELES, CA, 9/5/18) — The Trump Administration has cut all funding to the United Nations Relief and Works Agency for Palestinian Refugees (UNRWA). Created after the 1948 war which displaced 700,000 Palestinians, UNRWA works in collaboration with local governments to provide direct relief and resources aiding economic reintegration.
The agency provides food access, education, health clinics, employment, and housing services for Palestinians across the West Bank, Gaza, Jordan, Lebanon, and Syria. Previous administrations have viewed the agency as critical to stability in the region.
The State Department, Pentagon, and U.S. intelligence agencies have opposed defunding UNRWA. Security experts in the region have called the “de-registering” of refugees disastrous, worsening the humanitarian situation in Gaza. Both U.S. and regional experts have warned of increased violence undermining security in the region as a result. Months after announcing it was withholding $65 million of a $125 million aid package earmarked for the agency, the administration has decided to end all funding– while maintaining the nearly $4 billion in mostly military aid to Israel annually.
Defunding UNRWA is seen as part of a larger plan by the administration to reduce the number of Palestinians recognized as refugees. Leaked emails reveal Jared Kushner is trying “to disrupt UNRWA” and remove Palestinian refugee rights from the negotiating table. The plan is to reduce the number of Palestinians recognized as refugees from 5 million to less than a tenth of that number – effectively eliminating the “right of return” for most Palestinians.
These actions also tie into the administration’s recent move of the US embassy to Jerusalem. The recognition of Jerusalem as Israel’s capital and the defunding of UNRWA is part of a broader policy shift by this administration to reshape Middle East policy, and specifically the Palestinian-Israeli peace agreement. The right of return is considered a fundamental issue in negotiations for a peace agreement. However, coupled with the U.S. embassy move to Jerusalem and recognizing Jerusalem as the capital of Israel further de-legitimizes the U.S.’s credibility as an honest and fair broker of peace negotiations.
Despite the administration’s efforts, the U.N. General Assembly has reapproved UNRWA’s mandate and terms by a massive majority every three years since the agency’s inception. Last week the German government pledged to increase UNRWA funding and, indicated other nations will need to follow suit to make up for the deficit caused by the US. Jordan’s foreign minister Ayman Safadi warned of the decision’s potential of being “extremely destabilizing”. A retired Israeli military spokesman, Lt. Col. Peter Lerner explained defunding UNRWA, “in an abrupt way will cause the situation to spiral out of control. That’s not good for Israel or the Palestinians.”
The administration’s actions not only seems to dismantle peace negotiation efforts, it clearly and further swings the pendulum in favor of Israel. The impact of this decision will have lasting ramifications possibly crippling U.S. diplomatic efforts beyond the term of this administration and may damage the U.S.’s ability to serve as a mediator in future international conflicts.